Home / Services / Benchmarking and should-cost

Benchmarking and should-cost

What a part should cost to make in China, and who can make it.

Novie builds part should-costs and engineering effort estimates bottom-up, from the scope and the standards, before any supplier quote is read. China price benchmarks name one reference model per row. Supplier searches cover China, Korea and Japan, with evidence of capability for every name on the list.

Work items delivered in 2026
28
Deliverable types
5
Sources used
Dated 2024 or newer
Electronic control unit parts laid out on a dark surface

Five deliverables, each delivered in 2026

Each can be ordered on its own. The right-hand column names work already handed over, with the client left out.

DeliverableWhat it containsExample delivered
Part should-costMaterials, conversion, scrap and logistics. Tooling excluded. Supplier margin shown on its own.Steering control unit cost study, against a China vehicle and a German vehicle
Engineering effort bottom-up (ED&T, ED&D)Person-months by WBS, discipline and role, built from the RFQ, the ESOW, ASPICE 3.1 and ISO 26262.Powertrain control software for three vehicle programmes
China price benchmarkOne reference model per row: model year, variant, trim and market.Air suspension supply unit, five China suppliers
Supplier identificationQualified suppliers in China, Korea and Japan, with evidence of capability.Wire harness Tier-2 sources (tube, tape, cable), more than 20 qualified
Cost-down ideasIdeas tested through a five-gate validation before they reach the client.Eight ADAS sensor initiatives, ten vehicles benchmarked

What a benchmark row looks like

One named reference model per row. The cost to make is built up from its parts; the supplier margin stays in its own column.

Sample layout. Figures removed. Tooling sits outside the piece price.
Reference model (sample layout)SupplierMaterialsConversionScrap, logisticsCost to makeSupplier margin
MY2025, variant, trim, ChinaChina supplier A
MY2026, variant, trim, ChinaChina supplier B

Six rules behind every number

They apply on every job, so a client can trace any figure back to its source.

Built before the quote

A bottom-up must be buildable before the supplier quote arrives. The quote enters only as a comparison column.

Compared in person-months

Engineering effort is compared in person-months. Money comes in only at the supplier's own rate.

Sized by sourcing mode

Development effort follows the mode: off-the-shelf, build-to-print, adapt-to-fit or system integration.

Recent sources only

Sources date from 2024 onward. Older material counts as history.

Two languages, then the field

Chinese and English sources are checked separately, then confirmed on the ground.

Versioned tables

Master tables carry a version and a change log on every release.

Three cases from 2026

Clients are anonymised. Results are stated without client figures.

Is this engineering quote right?

Challenge
A premium OEM received a software engineering quote for three powertrain programmes.
Solution
Effort rebuilt from the scope and ASPICE work products before the quote was opened.
Result
Quoted effort challenged line by line, each with its basis.

Who in China can make this?

Challenge
A premium OEM needed Tier-2 wire harness sources in China.
Solution
Tube, tape and cable makers screened for automotive capability.
Result
More than 20 suppliers qualified.

Where is the gap against China?

Challenge
A premium OEM wanted an off-the-shelf alternative for an air suspension supply unit.
Solution
Five China suppliers benchmarked against the reference part.
Result
Benchmark adopted into the customer's own cost project.

Have a part, a quote or a supplier list to check?

Talk to us